Skip to content

TheSeer

For The Mindful Individual

  • Book Reviews
  • Bookmarks
    • Literature
    • Culture
    • Sociopolitical
    • Others
  • Interviews
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Events Coverage
    • The Seer Events
      • Singularity – Creative Learning Camps for Children
      • VoiceDabba – An Online Public Speaking Workshop for Children
      • Bangalore Reading Club Meetings
    • Partnered Events
      • BLF 2020
      • BLF 2019
      • BLF 2018
      • BLF 2017
      • BPF 2018
  • Contests
    • Kids
      • Young Reviewer Contest for Children – Winners Announced
      • StoryBaaz – A Story Writing Contest for Kids
    • Winning Entries
  • Our Services

A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings

December 1, 2017May 10, 2020 JeevaNayagiLeave a comment

It was the 10th Chennai International Film Festival. I surprised myself during the film festival that year by managing to watch a respectable number of films despite a hectic schedule at work. Michael Haneke’s Amour, which later went on to win the Academy Award for Best Picture, was also scheduled to be screened that year. It was on my must-watch list. I made it on time for the show and the movie was surely beautiful. However, I could not sit through the entire movie and had to walk out.

I am the kind of person who might cry through the entire movie giving my friends enough reasons to make fun of me, but walking out of a beautiful movie did not sound like me. Yet, I did. I walked out not because it was boring, but because the emotions captured in the movie was too painful and disturbing. It wasn’t that I fear difficult emotions or movies. In fact, I used to be one of the very few females among the audience during the screening of movies on subjects of violence, yet Amour was too much for me to take. All these years, I never once thought of watching it again, until recently.

‘A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings’ was screened this week at IIHS, in Bangalore. The event caught my attention probably because the title seemed to have been borrowed from Gabriel Garcia Marquez. I reached ten minutes late, sneaked in, took a seat at the darkest corner of the room and settled into what seemed like silent poetry. It is a feature film on the 4-feet 11-inches tall grandeur dearly known as ‘Pocket Hercules’. Like any traditional documentary films, this did not have a dozen people talking about the greatness of the much-celebrated Mr Universe Monohar Aich. Instead, Prateek Vats, the director of this film, takes you to the man himself. It is as if you were given the privilege to sit beside him, watch him from close quarters as he goes on about his day, and hear him breathe through a 102-year-old body.

Thirty years, and I have so much to complain about life. And there was Mr Aich who had spent a 100 year and more, but his eyes still seemed to have their twinkle. There was a certain charm about him that makes you smile. Even when he seemed to have forgotten a lot of things and hardly speaks, every now and then he does something that reminded you of his flamboyance.

I do not have the expertise to comment on the cinematic excellence of the movie but I can talk to you about the emotions that this movie stirred within me. Every time the camera captured sound or music, there seemed a certain watchful silence underneath it just like a calmer ocean beneath a stormy sky. Every time the camera captured the stillness in his life, there was something distressing about it that I squirmed in my seat, restlessly. However, I must thank the director or probably the editor for making this beautiful blend of storm and calm. It was as if they knew, that I wouldn’t be able to survive another minute of that stillness or that noise, that they decided to cut to move to the next frame. An old footage of Monohar Aich’s interview along with his wife was a surprise addition. Sorry about the spoilers, but that, I believe, gives a quick insight into the kind of person he was, even for people who did not know him.

There were moments during the film when that familiar feeling of discomfort, which happened during Amour was coming back to me. This was because both these films bring you the reality of old age in very intimate details. It’s a terrifying to even think that someday you will forget who you were. You will have no memory of your life’s deeds and will become entirely dependent on people around you. While I thoroughly empathize with the frustration and helplessness of any family that is taking care of an elderly person, it’s petrifying to learn that despite everything that you have accomplished, your own people will be disappointed in you. You might have to spend every minute of every day looking forward to nothing. But, somewhere the film also gives me the courage to deal with my fear of growing old and helpless. I might as well watch Amour soon.

The timing of the movie’s screening can’t get too perfect since it has been only a few days since Manushi Chillar brought home the Miss World Crown. It is amusing to watch our leaders wage war over twitter about how she must be rewarded. For all the gender equality we talk about, it is interesting to note that we as a nation have celebrated all our Miss World and Miss Universe winners. How many in our Mister Universe or Mister World winners do we even know about? That brings me to the next point about which the movie doesn’t talk about directly but gently nudges you to ponder upon. We are a young and dynamic nation, but we seem to have forgotten to plan on taking care of our elderly. We have left them at the mercy of their children who too, are caught up in the troubles of life, with less or no time to attend to the needs of the older generation. The life of Monohar Aich is a classic example of institutional negligence. The movie reminds us of how it’s about time we think about a wholesome plan for geriatric care in the country and also set up a standard procedure to acknowledge the accomplishment of people who represent the country in the International arena.

At the end of the screening, I wanted to thank Prateek and his team for having done this because this is going to be a very significant artefact for anyone who wants to study Mr Monohar Aich. But then the movie was too overwhelming for me, to talk then. So, I decided to write.

To Prateek Vats and his team – Thank you very much for doing this. I can only imagine the amount of labour and patience this would have needed. Hats off to the sensitivity and compassion your guys displayed throughout.

To my readers – Watch out for the screening of this movie in your city. This is a movie you might want to sit tight and watch, irrespective of whether you knew Mr Aich. I say so because the movie is not merely about Mr Aich but also about life in flesh and blood.

Here is a two-minute-long excerpt from the movie.

Public Libraries in the Digital Age

November 6, 2017May 16, 2019 TheSeer TeamLeave a comment

The speaker of the house was Hannelore Vogt with Satish Hosamani, the former is the director of Cologne Public Library, Germany and the latter represented Karnataka State Libraries. The session started with Hannelore presenting us some articles which looked like toys and one would wonder about its significance, only to realise from her presentation that those were printed out from the 3D printer of Hannelore’s public library.

Continue reading “Public Libraries in the Digital Age” →

First Draft to Marketing – How to get Published

November 6, 2017May 16, 2019 TheSeer TeamLeave a comment

The author of ‘The Amazing Racist’, ‘Panther’, and ‘Loyal Stalkers’, Tenduf-La grew up in a bunch of cities that includes Hong Kong, London, Delhi, and Colombo. Through his own experiences, Chhimi Tenduf-La brings the nuances in the pursuit of getting a book published.

Continue reading “First Draft to Marketing – How to get Published” →

The Family as a Microcosm

November 6, 2017May 16, 2019 TheSeer TeamLeave a comment

Bangaloreans got a chance to interact face to face with the renowned author Sadiqa Peerbhoy, who launched her latest book on the first day of Bangalore Literature Festival, 2017. ‘The Family as a Microcosm’ is the story of a dysfunctional family which is trying to survive through a distraught Bombay, post-Babri Masjid demolition. While both the family and the city are in turmoil, the author tries to portray how deeply the fate of both these two entities are intertwined. Whatever happens to the family, happens to the city and hence, the word ‘microcosm’ fits so aptly into the title.

Continue reading “The Family as a Microcosm” →

Crime Vs. Politics

November 6, 2017July 5, 2025 Abhishek JhaLeave a comment

अपराध बनाम राजनीति।

अपराध क्या है? राजनीति क्या है? क्या दोनों एक दूसरे के पर्याय हैं, या फिर पूरक हैं? अपराध के बिना राजनीति के क्या मायने हैं और राजनीति की अनुपस्थिति में अपराध के क्या मायने हैं? इन बातों पर सोच रहा हूँ। सुबह का समय है। बेंगलूर का मौसम अभी बेतुका सा है। वो जो बच्चा होता है घर में, जिसे किसी ने बताया नहीं कि मेहमान के आने पर क्या करना होता है, मौसम का हाल अभी कुछ वैसा ही है। बारिश हो रही है और नहीं भी। हैइसेंबर्ग साहब को यह मौसम ज़रूर भाता।

हैइसेंबर्ग साहब की बात चली है तो उनको अपराध और राजनीति के पहलू पर भी तौल कर ही विदा करते हैं। ऐसा लगता है जैसे अगर आपने अपराध पर उंगली रख दी और कहा कि ये अपराध है, तो शायद आप राजनीति को कभी न समझ पाएँ और अगर राजनीति पर हाथ रख कर कह दिया कि यही राजनीति है तो शायद कभी अपराध न समझ पाएँ। प्रतिसाल रेलवे दुर्घटनाओं में हज़ारों लोग वीरगति को प्राप्त हो जाते हैं, वीरगति इसलिए कह रहा हूँ क्योंकि ये लोग जो ऐसी दुर्घटनाओं के बारे में सुनकर-पढ़कर भी रेल यातायात का त्याग नहीं करते, ये किसी वीर से कम तो नहीं। बात ऐसी हो गई है कि हाँ भई चलो, दुर्घटना होती है तो क्या, देश तो अपना है, मोदी जी अपने हैं, कुछ एक लोग मर भी जायें तो कौन सी आफत हो जाएगी। हर दुर्घटना के बाद पीड़ितों को कुछ मुआवज़ा मिलता है, कुछ एक मंत्री त्यागपत्र भी प्रेषित कर देते हैं पर कोई ऐसा माई का लाल पैदा नहीं हुआ जो इन दुर्घटनाओं को रोक दे। अब आपसे एक सवाल है, रेल दुर्घटनाएँ अपराध हैं या राजनीति? सोचिये।

मेरे पल्ले तो इतनी ही बात पड़ती है कि अगर किसी व्यक्ति ने रेल के डिब्बेे में घुसकर उतने ही लोगों को किसी हथियार से मार दिया होता तो हम सब उसको अपराध मानते। पुलिस केस इत्यादि झटपट शुरू हो जाते। दूरदर्शन पर ये देख कर कि हत्यारे को धर दबोचा गया है, हम चैन की साँस भी लेते। पर रेल दुर्घटनाओं में ऐसा कुछ नहीं होता क्योंकि वहाँ पर राजनीति इतराने लग जाती है। हमारी चुनी हुई सरकार और उस सरकार के चुने हुए अफसर यहाँ हमारे अपराधी हैं। इतना ही नहीं, पटरी की जांच करता लाइनमैन शायद हम जैसा ही कोई होगा जिस से कोई भूल हुई और कुछ अमंगल घटित हो गया। हमारी चुनी हुई सरकार को हमने देश के कल्याण हेतु कुछ अपराध करने की भी छूट दी हुई है।

इसको शायद डॉक्टर-रोगी रिश्ते के चश्मे से भी देखा जा सकता है। एक अच्छा डॉक्टर रोगी को चंगा देखना चाहता है और उसका इसी सोच के अनुसार उपचार करता है। पर ऐसे वैद्य अल्पसंख्यक ही होते हैं। हम सब रोगी हैं और हमारे देश की राजनीति दूसरे किस्म का वैद्य है जो चाहता है कि रोगी रोगी ही बना रहे ताकि वैद्य के घर का चूल्हा सूर्य की तरह निरंकुश जलता रहे। इस किस्म के वैद्य रोगी को स्वस्थ करने के वादे तो करते हैं पर असल में रोगी को बद से बदतर बनाते चले जाते हैं। ये वैद्य हमारे सरकारी कार्यालयों, दफ्तरों, मंत्रालयों में आपको मिल जायेंगे।

हमारी शिक्षा प्रणाली को ही ले लीजिए। जहाँ जहाँ सरकार ने पैर पसारे हैं, वहीं हमारे विद्यार्थियों का भविष्य क्षत-विक्षत हुआ है। देश में बहुत सारे सर्वे होते हैं, एक सर्वे ये भी किया जाये कि कितने नेताओं के बच्चे सरकारी स्कूलों में पढ़ने जाते हैं। उधर उच्चतर शिक्षा के लिए बैंक से ऋण लेने के लिए एक गरीब विद्यार्थी को 11-12 प्रतिशत का ब्याज चुकाना पड़ता है। वहीं कार ऋण 9 से 10 के आसपास घूमता है और घर के लिए ऋण 8 से 9 के बीच मे रखा गया है। ये तो सिर्फ आंकड़े हैं पर पढ़ाई के लिए ऋण लेने में कितने पापड़ बेलने पड़ते हैं, ये विद्यार्थियों से पूछना चाहिए। अगर बिना पैरवी के आपको शिक्षा ऋण मिल जाता है तो आप खुद को एक दिन अमरीका के राष्ट्रपति के रूप में देख लें तो कोई आश्चर्य नहीं। राजनीतिज्ञ कौन है, ये तो मुझे नहीं पता पर इतना ज़रूर पता है कि ये पूरा राजनैतिक ढांचा हमारा अपराधी है और इसको कटघरे में खड़ा करना हमारा धर्म।

कुछ लोग कोशिश करते हैं पर चूँकि वे अल्पसंख्यक ही हैं, उनको डंडे से चुप करा दिया जाता है। इन सब अपराधों के बीच में अगर कोई कार्टूनिस्ट अपना विरोध अपनी कला के माध्यम से व्यक्त करता है तो सरकारी गलियारों में खलबली मच जाती है और उसे ‘पल में परलय होयगी, बहुरि करैगा कब’ के सिद्धांत पर अविलंब बंदी बना लिया जाता है। सवाल ये उठता है कि बंदी कौन होना चाहिए। कारागार में वो कार्टूनिस्ट होना चाहिए या वो नेता और अफसर जिन्होंने एलफिंस्टन पुल के ख़स्ता हालत पर सारी सूचनाओं और चेतावनियों को हवा में उड़ा दिया?

आप सोचें। मैं भी सोचता हूँ। कुछ समय बाद फिर मिलेंगे कुछ और विचार लेकर। लोकतंत्र को प्रणाम।

Image Credits – https://www.justpo.st/post/7181

Voyage of Words – Translators Set Sail

November 3, 2017May 16, 2019 TheSeer TeamLeave a comment
Mini Krishnan, a well-known publisher, drove the session with Kannan Sundaram, a publisher in Tamil and MS Asha Devi and Subhashree Krishnaswamy, prominent literary translators to emphasize the dynamics and challenges of the literary translation, an art that often goes unacknowledged. The translators discussed theoretical and practical aspects of their translation experience, and critical statements on the extent, quality, consistency, and impact of the translator’s work. The publishers shared their views on choosing the right books to publish.

Continue reading “Voyage of Words – Translators Set Sail” →

Antara Gange

November 3, 2017May 16, 2019 TheSeer TeamLeave a comment

Women who have been through the toughest of times that life has thrown at them, Indira Lankesh and Dr. Vijaya opened in this interaction with M S Asha Devi about what makes them the strong women they are. Indira Lankesh is the wife of Late P Lankesh and author of , ‘Sour Mango and I’ (autobiography), and Dr. Vijaya, the first woman journalist in Kannada, was the one who brought the International Film Festival to Bangalore.  She also launched the intellectual magazine for women, ‘Namma Manasa’. M S Asha Devi, a feminist writer elicits the working of the minds of these women who embodied strength.

Continue reading “Antara Gange” →

Jingoism Vs. Patriotism

November 3, 2017May 16, 2019 Abhishek JhaLeave a comment

Weekend mornings of an octoberish Bangalore can carry you into an inertia that is extremely difficult to overcome. However, this is a time loved and awaited by writers, poets, and patrons of literature for reasons transcending into the creative streak of such people. As such, this is perhaps the best time for a celebration like Bangalore Literature Festival to happen. When you have a Historian and Author as eminent as Ramachandra Guha to speak with you right in the morning, you can’t really ask for more. ‘Jingoism Vs. Patriotism’ has been a lingering debate for a long time in our society and has gained refreshed vitality in the recent times. Guha spoke on this subject. Continue reading “Jingoism Vs. Patriotism” →

The City as a Protagonist

November 3, 2017May 16, 2019 JeevaNayagiLeave a comment

How often do we flow into the city and see it as a living, breathing space that weaves in memories? Imraan Coovadia, the author of five novels (‘The Wedding, ‘Tales of the Metric System’, to name a few), Suketu Mehta of ‘Maximum City’ fame, in conversation with Ravi Singh of ‘Speaking Tiger’ were in to discuss the workings of the city, and what these residents bring to help the cities thrive. Both authors bring in their experience of being in multiple cities in their lives, tracing it from their forefathers seeking to move out of their cities in India to cities elsewhere around the globe. Continue reading “The City as a Protagonist” →

Whose Side are You On?

November 3, 2017May 16, 2019 JeevaNayagiLeave a comment

Two of the most prominent sports writers and columnists sat to deliberate on the ever-changing landscape of the game of cricket. As T20s shatter all records of sports viewership and fandom and the International cricket based on the idea of nation loyalties paves way for the domestic leagues of T20s, Gideon Haigh and Suresh Menon discussed the significance of modern cricket dynamics and the future of fandom in the session titled ‘Whose side are you on?’.

Continue reading “Whose Side are You On?” →

History of the Kannada Script and Language

November 3, 2017May 16, 2019 TheSeer Team1 Comment
Pulling in a 1600-year timeline of the evolution of a language so dear to its folk in its homeland into a half an hour slot is a task that could very well be passed off as a herculean task. Yet, Dr S. Settar brought in the history of Kannada, with the clearest of details with ease. Dr Settar is a prolific writer in two languages- English and Kannada- and his themes pan across languages, art-history, religions, and the likes.

Continue reading “History of the Kannada Script and Language” →

சாதியும் நானும் – Caste and I

November 3, 2017July 5, 2025 JeevaNayagiLeave a comment

“Caste haunts you in the food that you eat. It might offer a moment of solace through community support. It might even offer you a god but there are more disadvantages to it”, says Ambai (C.S.Lakshmi) who has translated the Perumal Murugan’s ‘சாதியும் நானும்’ into English. The book is titled, “Caste and I” which was also the subject of discussion of conversation between Ambai, Perumal Murugan and the publisher Kannan Sundaram.

The book is an anthology of 32 essays written by people from 20 different castes. The original version in Tamil was released during the 50th meeting of Koodu in Namakkal. The contributors of these articles were not mainstream writers but students and other acquaintances of Perumal Murugan who have either been victims of casteism or have not had the courage to give up on casteism. The articles were personal experiences of these contributors.

Ambai talks about the various intriguing tales from the book which affected her greatly.
– A young boy from the lower caste who was not allowed to sit in the swirling chair of a salon because the hairdresser was afraid that his customers from upper caste will shun his salon for letting a lower caste boy sit on it.
– A dying patient who asked his doctor for his caste.
– A student who was mockingly called Rajiv Gandhi by his friends because he was provided with the Rajiv Gandhi scholarship for scheduled caste.
– A child from the lower caste who was given black coffee in a coconut shell because the dominant caste believed that serving milk to the lower caste would dry up the cow.

Ambai recollects how the courtesy of offering water to a guest when you enter a household in the rural Tamil Nadu was a subtle way of enquiring about her caste. Not just the rural area, even in the urban set up there indeed are people who refuse to rent out houses to Muslims and Dalits, added Murugan.

Perumal Murugan while talking about the book and the experiences that affected him says, it wasn’t an easy task to put the book together. People were hesitant to talk openly about caste and how it played out in their lives. But when they spoke about it eventually their worst fears came true. Some of them lost friends and relative severed ties with them. However, there were also good things that came out of it. When a friend from the upper caste wrote about how he could not bring his friends home because his family was against it and how small he felt about it, their friendship only got stronger. Some of them could take off their chest, the pain, humiliation and guilt that they had carried forever, by writing about it.

Perumal also talks about two essays that he wrote when his mother passed away. In one of the essays, he talks about his relationship with his mother and how she herself was a casteist. His mother did not approve of his marriage initially since it was an inter-caste marriage but did come to love her daughter in law later. But what shocked him the most was that even when her memory was slipping due to Parkinson’s disease she did not approve of the Dalit girl who was attending to her. Casteism is so deeply ingrained the blood of our people and we continue to pretend as if it does not matter. Ambai has translated these two articles into English and they were published in Sparrow.

He also remarks how even today there are different burial grounds and cemetery for different castes in the villages of Tamilnadu and how his mother insisted that he pay taxes to multiple villages to ensure she gets a burial ground. He also humorously adds that when his mother passed away it was the electric cemetery came to his rescue. When people ask him about where he has kept (buried) his mother, he continues to points to his heart.

Posts navigation

Older posts
Newer posts

Become TheSeer Insider

Press Like to Stay Updated on Facebook

Press Like to Stay Updated on Facebook

Most Read Articles

  • The Absurdity We Live With: On the Meaninglessness of Life
    The Absurdity We Live With: On the Meaninglessness of Life
  • Condolence Message on the Mahasamadhi of Srimat Swami Shashankananda
    Condolence Message on the Mahasamadhi of Srimat Swami Shashankananda
  • Ichiro Kishimi, Fumitake Koga, and Oscar Trimboli Walk into My Library...
    Ichiro Kishimi, Fumitake Koga, and Oscar Trimboli Walk into My Library...
  • Why the Ayodhya Ram Mandir Represents a Collective Catharsis for the Indian Mind
    Why the Ayodhya Ram Mandir Represents a Collective Catharsis for the Indian Mind
  • Reverie Under the Bangalore Clouds
    Reverie Under the Bangalore Clouds
  • Why You Should’t Pixel(8) Your Life Any Further?
    Why You Should’t Pixel(8) Your Life Any Further?

Join Us

Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new articles by email.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • About Us
  • In Media
  • Write With Us
  • Contact Us
Proudly powered by WordPress | Theme: Pena by Anariel Design.